Arkinu
AWS service comparison

AWS DataSync vs AWS Transfer Family: differences and when to use each

AWS DataSync
AWS Transfer Family

Often confused on the examQuestions tend to offer one as a distractor for the other: look for the phrase in the scenario that tips the balance.

Migration and Transfer

AWS DataSync

Online data transfer service that copies files or objects between on-premises storage (NFS, SMB, HDFS, or object storage), other clouds, and AWS services such as Amazon S3, Amazon EFS, and Amazon FSx. It automates the transfer with encryption and data integrity validation.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «migrate terabytes of files from an on-premises NAS over NFS or SMB to Amazon S3, Amazon EFS, or Amazon FSx over the network»

    DataSync is the AWS online transfer service: an agent reads the on-premises storage over NFS or SMB and copies the data to S3, EFS, or FSx, with encryption, integrity verification, and bandwidth control.

    When not: If the network cannot move the volume within the required time, a physical transfer fits: AWS Snowball Edge is no longer offered to new customers and AWS suggests AWS Data Transfer Terminal or partner solutions. If on-premises applications must keep accessing the files already moved, AWS Storage Gateway fits.

  • «periodically sync on-premises data with AWS until the cutover day»

    DataSync tasks can be scheduled and, on each run, copy only what changed since the previous one; this keeps the destination up to date until the cutover.

    When not: If what must be kept in sync is a database with ongoing changes, the tool is AWS DMS with CDC; if it is entire servers, AWS Transform MGN (formerly AWS Application Migration Service).

  • «copy data between Amazon EFS, Amazon FSx, and Amazon S3, even across Regions, without writing scripts»

    Between AWS storage services in the same account, DataSync copies without an agent, within a Region or across Regions, with scheduling and verification.

    When not: To continuously copy objects from one bucket to another, S3 Replication fits better; to apply an action to millions of objects, S3 Batch Operations.

  • «copy data from another cloud provider to Amazon S3»

    DataSync supports storage from other clouds (for example, Google Cloud Storage or Azure) as a source and copies it to S3 on a schedule, with verification.

    When not: If the requirement is for external users or partners to upload files over SFTP, FTPS, or AS2, the answer is AWS Transfer Family: DataSync does not offer a file server for third parties.

  • «verify that the copied data is identical to the source»

    DataSync checks integrity during the copy and, optionally, compares the source and destination checksums at the end, in addition to producing reports for each run.

    When not: If you use tools such as rsync or the S3 CLI, you have to build that verification by hand; if the shipment is physical, the verification depends on that process (for example, Snowball Edge produces a report with the checksums of each file), not on DataSync.

Often paired with

  • Amazon S3
  • Amazon EFS
  • Amazon FSx
Study AWS DataSync →

Migration and Transfer

AWS Transfer Family

Fully managed service for transferring files into and out of Amazon S3 or Amazon EFS using SFTP, FTPS, FTP, AS2, or a web browser. It lets you move file exchange workflows to AWS without changing client configurations or operating your own servers.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «business partners send files over SFTP and cannot change their clients or their scripts»

    Transfer Family offers a fully managed SFTP endpoint (also FTPS, FTP, and AS2) that stores the files directly in Amazon S3 or Amazon EFS; partners keep using their usual clients.

    When not: If the one moving the data is the company itself, from its on-premises NAS to AWS, the clue points to AWS DataSync. If on-premises applications need to mount an NFS or SMB share backed by S3, to AWS Storage Gateway.

  • «eliminate the self-managed SFTP servers that have to be patched and maintained»

    The service removes the operation of transfer servers: AWS manages availability and scaling, and you configure users, permissions, and storage.

    When not: If what is costly to operate is something else, for example a message broker, the equivalent managed service is a different one (Amazon MQ). The clue is the file transfer protocol.

  • «exchange signed and encrypted B2B documents with delivery receipts using AS2»

    Transfer Family supports AS2, the usual protocol in retail and supply chain for exchanging signed, encrypted files with delivery confirmation (MDN).

    When not: If neither AS2 nor a file protocol is required, and what has to be integrated is data from SaaS applications, think of Amazon AppFlow; if it is events, Amazon EventBridge.

  • «automatically process each file right after the partner uploads it (decrypt, copy, tag)»

    Transfer Family managed workflows run a sequence of steps on each file uploaded over SFTP, FTPS, or FTP: copy, tag, decrypt with PGP, or call a Lambda function, with steps to handle errors.

    When not: If the logic is conditional or has to integrate with many services, AWS suggests reacting to Transfer Family events with Amazon EventBridge. AS2 messages do not run workflows.

  • «partners must allowlist fixed IP addresses for the SFTP server»

    A VPC-hosted endpoint with internet-facing access lets you associate Elastic IPs, which do not change, so partners can allow them in their firewall.

    When not: With the public endpoint type there are no fixed IPs. And if the requirement is a custom name such as sftp.company.com, what you need is Route 53 (or another DNS), not the IPs.

Often paired with

  • Amazon S3
  • Amazon EFS
Study AWS Transfer Family →