Arkinu
AWS service comparison

Amazon ECS Anywhere vs Amazon EKS Anywhere: differences and when to use each

Amazon ECS Anywhere
Amazon EKS Anywhere

Often confused on the examQuestions tend to offer one as a distractor for the other: look for the phrase in the scenario that tips the balance.

Containers

Amazon ECS Anywhere

Amazon ECS capability that lets you register your own on-premises servers or virtual machines as external instances of an ECS cluster. This lets you run and manage containers outside AWS with the same Amazon ECS.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «run containers on your own servers while managing them with Amazon ECS from the cloud»

    ECS Anywhere registers your own physical servers or virtual machines as external instances of an ECS cluster, so you use the same tools and the same control plane as in AWS, without installing your own orchestrator.

    When not: If the organization uses Kubernetes, the answer is Amazon EKS Anywhere. If you want AWS-managed hardware inside the data center, think of AWS Outposts.

  • «manage on-premises and AWS containers with the same tools, and migrate them later»

    A single ECS cluster can mix on-premises servers, EC2 instances, and Fargate, which makes it easier to move workloads to the cloud later.

    When not: If there is no intention to use AWS for orchestration and no connection to the Region, ECS Anywhere adds nothing: it depends on the control plane in the cloud.

  • «process data on premises and have only management information reach AWS»

    Only management information (host health, container start and stop, health checks) travels to the Region; the data that the containers process stays on the local server.

    When not: If you send the containers' logs to CloudWatch or pull images from ECR, that traffic does leave for AWS. And if the environment is isolated from the internet (air-gapped), ECS Anywhere is not an option.

  • «on-premises applications that generate outbound traffic or process batches of data»

    External instances are designed for workloads that process data or generate outbound traffic, such as processing jobs close to where the data is.

    When not: If the application receives inbound traffic and needs a load balancer, ECS Anywhere is a poor fit: it does not support service load balancing or service discovery. A web application like that would go on ECS on EC2 or Fargate.

Study Amazon ECS Anywhere →

Containers

Amazon EKS Anywhere

Amazon EKS option for creating and operating Kubernetes clusters on your own infrastructure. It helps you run applications the same way in the cloud and on premises, for example when data must stay on site.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «run Kubernetes in your own data center with no internet connection»

    EKS Anywhere can run connected or fully disconnected (air-gapped): the clusters live in your infrastructure and do not depend on an AWS Region.

    When not: If the site is connected and you prefer AWS to manage the control plane, Amazon EKS Hybrid Nodes fits. If AWS hardware in your own data center is acceptable, Amazon EKS on AWS Outposts.

  • «use the same Kubernetes distribution as Amazon EKS on your own premises, with tooling to create and upgrade clusters»

    EKS Anywhere is based on Amazon EKS Distro and adds the tooling to install, upgrade, and operate clusters on vSphere, bare metal, Nutanix, CloudStack, or AWS Snowball Edge (which is no longer offered to new customers).

    When not: If you only want the Kubernetes components and you assemble and operate the cluster yourself with your own tools, that is Amazon EKS Distro. In the AWS Cloud, AWS recommends Amazon EKS.

  • «data must stay on site and the cluster must run on existing servers»

    With EKS Anywhere, applications run on Kubernetes on your own hardware or your VMware vSphere, so the data does not leave the site and you use the infrastructure that already exists.

    When not: If there is no Kubernetes requirement and orchestrating containers on your own servers is enough, Amazon ECS Anywhere is simpler. And remember that with EKS Anywhere AWS manages neither the cluster nor the capacity: the customer does.

  • «view in the AWS console the Kubernetes clusters that run outside AWS»

    A connected EKS Anywhere cluster can be registered with EKS Connector and appear in the Amazon EKS console alongside the other clusters.

    When not: EKS Connector only shows the cluster; it does not let you manage it from the console. And it needs outbound access to the AWS Systems Manager endpoints, so it does not work on an air-gapped site.

  • «AWS support for Kubernetes on your own premises»

    With an EKS Anywhere Enterprise subscription you get AWS support for the clusters, instead of depending on different vendors for each piece.

    When not: Without a subscription you can use the software, but without that support. If what you want is for AWS to operate the control plane, the answer is Amazon EKS (in the Region, on Outposts, or with Hybrid Nodes).

Study Amazon EKS Anywhere →