Arkinu
AWS service comparison

Amazon ECS vs Amazon EKS: differences and when to use each

Amazon ECS
Amazon EKS

Often confused on the examQuestions tend to offer one as a distractor for the other: look for the phrase in the scenario that tips the balance.

Containers

Amazon ECS

Fully managed container orchestration service for deploying, managing, and scaling containerized applications without operating a control plane. Containers can run on Amazon EC2 instances (managed by you or by AWS with Amazon ECS Managed Instances), on AWS Fargate (no servers to manage), or on your own servers with Amazon ECS Anywhere.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «orchestrate containers without installing or operating your own control plane»

    Amazon ECS is the AWS managed container orchestrator: it decides where tasks run, maintains the desired count, replaces the ones that fail, and integrates with Elastic Load Balancing, IAM, and the VPC.

    When not: If the scenario requires Kubernetes (Kubernetes manifests, tooling, or portability), the answer is Amazon EKS. If there are no containers but short pieces of code that react to events, think of AWS Lambda.

  • «run containers on Amazon ECS without managing EC2 instances»

    With Fargate as the capacity, ECS launches each task without any instances to choose, patch, or scale; you only define the task's CPU and memory.

    When not: If you need a GPU, your own AMI, privileged containers, or a specific instance type, use ECS on EC2 instances (or ECS Managed Instances, where AWS manages those instances).

  • «give each container only the permissions it needs to access other AWS services»

    The task's IAM role provides temporary credentials to the containers in that task, so each service has its own least-privilege role without relying on the instance role.

    When not: The permissions to pull the image from ECR, send logs to CloudWatch, or read secrets referenced in the task definition go in the task execution role, not in the task role.

  • «adjust the number of tasks based on CPU, requests, or queued messages»

    ECS publishes CPU and memory metrics for each service, and Application Auto Scaling raises or lowers the number of tasks based on them or on custom CloudWatch metrics, such as the messages in a queue.

    When not: With EC2 instances you also have to scale the instances (with an Auto Scaling group capacity provider); with Fargate you don't. If what needs to scale isn't containers, use EC2 Auto Scaling or Lambda.

  • «several container services behind a single load balancer, routed by path»

    ECS registers and deregisters tasks in the target group automatically; with dynamic ports and Application Load Balancer path-based rules, several services share one load balancer.

    When not: If you need TCP/UDP traffic with very low latency, think of Network Load Balancer. If only internal services talk to each other, ECS Service Connect provides logical names without a load balancer.

Often paired with

  • Amazon ECR
  • AWS Fargate
  • Elastic Load Balancing (ELB)
  • Amazon EC2
Study Amazon ECS →

Containers

Amazon EKS

Fully managed Kubernetes service: AWS operates the cluster control plane for you. It lets you run Kubernetes-compatible applications without modification, in the AWS Cloud and also in your own data centers.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «run Kubernetes on AWS without managing the control plane»

    In Amazon EKS, AWS operates each cluster's control plane (the API server and etcd) spread across multiple Availability Zones, patches it, and replaces whatever fails. You only take care of the nodes and your applications.

    When not: If the scenario does not require Kubernetes and only asks to run containers in the simplest way, Amazon ECS is usually a better fit. If the cluster must live in your own data center with no connection to AWS, think of Amazon EKS Anywhere.

  • «migrate applications that already run on Kubernetes without modifying them»

    EKS runs standard (upstream) Kubernetes, so manifests, charts, and community tools keep working without code changes.

    When not: If the company does not use Kubernetes and doesn't want to learn it, this clue is not enough: Amazon ECS or AWS Fargate with ECS reduce complexity. If what you are migrating is virtual machines, not containers, think of Amazon EC2.

  • «give each pod only the IAM permissions it needs»

    With IAM roles for service accounts (IRSA), an IAM role is associated with a Kubernetes service account and only the pods that use it receive its temporary credentials, instead of inheriting the node's role. AWS now recommends EKS Pod Identity whenever possible, which achieves the same with less configuration.

    When not: In Amazon ECS the equivalent piece is the task role. And if the question is about who can administer the cluster, the answer goes through access to the Kubernetes API, not through the pods' permissions.

  • «use your own servers as nodes while AWS manages the control plane»

    Amazon EKS Hybrid Nodes lets you join machines from your own premises or the edge to an EKS cluster whose control plane AWS still manages in the Region.

    When not: Hybrid Nodes requires a connection to the Region. If the site is air-gapped, use Amazon EKS Anywhere; if you want AWS hardware in your own data center, Amazon EKS on AWS Outposts.

  • «reduce the cost of the cluster's nodes for workloads that tolerate interruptions»

    EKS managed node groups can be created with Spot capacity; EKS applies best practices such as capacity rebalancing and tries to drain nodes before they are interrupted.

    When not: Stateful workloads or workloads that don't tolerate interruptions (databases, StatefulSets) go on On-Demand nodes. And EKS pods on Fargate do not support Fargate Spot.

Often paired with

  • Amazon ECR
  • Amazon EC2
  • AWS Fargate
  • Elastic Load Balancing (ELB)
Study Amazon EKS →