Arkinu
AWS service comparison

Amazon EFS vs Amazon FSx: differences and when to use each

Amazon EFS
Amazon FSx

Often confused on the examQuestions tend to offer one as a distractor for the other: look for the phrase in the scenario that tips the balance.

Storage

Amazon EFS

Serverless, elastic file system, accessible through the NFS protocol, that grows and shrinks automatically as you add or delete files. It lets many Amazon EC2 instances, containers, or AWS Lambda functions share the same files without provisioning capacity; it is not supported on Windows instances.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «a shared file system accessed by multiple Linux instances at the same time»

    Amazon EFS is a managed NFS file system: many instances mount it at the same time and see the same files, with file locking included.

    When not: If the clients are Windows and use SMB, the answer is usually Amazon FSx for Windows File Server. If the disk is used by a single instance (for example, a self-managed database), Amazon EBS fits.

  • «mount the same storage from instances in multiple Availability Zones»

    A Regional EFS file system stores data across several zones and supports a mount target in each one, so instances in different zones share the same data and the file system survives the loss of a zone.

    When not: If you choose EFS One Zone to save money, the data lives in a single zone and does not survive its loss. And if what you need is a block disk for an instance, Amazon EBS cannot be shared across zones.

  • «file storage that grows and shrinks automatically, without provisioning capacity»

    EFS is elastic: you pay for what you store and do not have to reserve a size in advance.

    When not: If the data is read and written as objects over HTTP or an API (website images, a data lake), Amazon S3 is usually more suitable and cheaper. If you need an extreme-performance parallel file system for HPC, think of Amazon FSx for Lustre.

  • «reduce the cost of files that are rarely accessed, without changing the application»

    With lifecycle management, EFS automatically moves files that are not being used to the Infrequent Access or Archive classes; the application still sees them at the same path.

    When not: If the data is objects in a bucket, the equivalent tool is Amazon S3 lifecycle rules. And if cold files are read frequently and latency matters, it is best to have them return to Standard on first access.

  • «persistent, shared storage for Lambda functions or containers on Fargate»

    Both AWS Lambda and Amazon ECS (with EC2 or Fargate) can mount an EFS file system, and the data survives each invocation or task.

    When not: If you only need temporary space during execution, the service's own ephemeral storage is enough. If the data is stored as objects, Amazon S3 is the simplest option.

Often paired with

  • Amazon EC2
  • AWS Lambda
Study Amazon EFS →

Storage

Amazon FSx

Service for launching, running, and scaling widely used high-performance file systems in the cloud: Windows File Server, Lustre, NetApp ONTAP, and OpenZFS. It is used when a workload needs the specific capabilities of one of those file systems.

Exam phrases that point here

  • «file shares for Windows applications, over SMB and with Active Directory permissions»

    Amazon FSx for Windows File Server is a managed Windows file server: it speaks SMB, joins the Active Directory domain, and honors the NTFS ACLs the company already uses.

    When not: If the clients are Linux and NFS is enough, Amazon EFS is simpler and more elastic. If you need NFS or iSCSI over the same data in addition to SMB, FSx for NetApp ONTAP is a better fit.

  • «high performance computing (HPC) or machine learning training on data stored in Amazon S3»

    Amazon FSx for Lustre is a parallel file system with very high throughput that links to an S3 bucket: it presents the objects as files and loads their content when they are read.

    When not: If the workload only needs a shared Linux file system without extreme performance, Amazon EFS is enough. FSx for Lustre only has Linux clients and is deployed in a single Availability Zone.

  • «very high-performance temporary storage for short-lived processing»

    The FSx for Lustre scratch deployment is designed for temporary, cost-optimized jobs: it does not replicate data, which stays safe in the linked S3 bucket.

    When not: If the data must be kept for months or withstand server failures, choose the FSx for Lustre persistent deployment, not scratch.

  • «migrate a NetApp ONTAP NAS to AWS without changing tools or processes»

    Amazon FSx for NetApp ONTAP offers the same ONTAP features (such as SnapMirror) as a managed service, so migration and operation are done with what the team already knows.

    When not: If the source server is a Windows file server, FSx for Windows File Server fits; if it is ZFS or a Linux NFS server, FSx for OpenZFS.

  • «access the same data over NFS and SMB at the same time, or expose block storage over iSCSI»

    FSx for NetApp ONTAP is the FSx type with the most protocols: files over NFS and SMB on the same data, and block storage over iSCSI and NVMe/TCP.

    When not: If all the clients are Windows, FSx for Windows File Server is usually the direct answer; if all are Linux with NFS, Amazon EFS or FSx for OpenZFS.

  • «move ZFS or Linux NFS file servers to AWS without changing the application»

    Amazon FSx for OpenZFS offers a managed OpenZFS file system, accessible over NFS and with instant snapshots and clones.

    When not: If you prefer to provision neither capacity nor performance, Amazon EFS is more elastic. If you need SMB, OpenZFS does not offer it.

Study Amazon FSx →